Skip to main content
 

MMOs Face Patent Lawsuit
 Paul Younger 

General ScreenshotMMO developers and publishers are coming under fire from New York based Paltalk Holdings who have filed a lawsuit for patent infringement.

According to an article on Boston.com, Paltalk Holdings is to challenge MMO developers including Turbine, SOE,  NCSoft, Activision Blizzard and UK-based Jagex over patent infringment. Paltalk Holdings, which is a provider of software and technology for real-time, rich media, interactive social networking, is trying to protect two patents covering "methods for deploying interactive applications over hosted networks and group messaging servers." In other words, two computers connected to an online world that see and share content fall into this category, according to Paltalk.

The complaint has been filed at the District Court in Marshall Texas, the same location where Microsoft settled a case with Paltalk in 2006 over the same patents. Paltalk had alleged that Microsoft had been infringing its patents with Halo 2 and Halo 3 on Xbox Live.  On the fourth day of the trial, Microsoft conceded and settled out of court. Microsoft subsequently licensed the patents for an undisclosed sum.

Being that Microsoft settled out of court, Paltalk may have a chance of success. The MMO developers/publishers under fire may have to take a similar route to Microsoft and pay a licensing fee to get the case settled.

N4G : News for Gamers

Related Info

EverQuest 2
Guild Wars: Eye of the North
The Lord of the Rings Online Shadows of Angmar
The Lord of the Rings Online: Mines of Moria
World of Warcraft
Guild Wars 2

User comments

(1) Posted: 02:23 on 17 Sep 2009
Hamsterman
Wow, pretty major deal. That patent must have been pretty water-tight for MS to buckle. Wonder what response the MMO devs will give?
(2) Posted: 06:41 on 17 Sep 2009
Valas Azuviir
Why is the patent still valid, considering there have been MMOs since 1995/1996 with Meridian 59.

Even if one were to go with the whole not aware of their existence thing, which is hard to believe considering they're supposed to be part of the IT world.

Then you'd still run into the same issues with Ultima Online, EQ, Star Wars Galaxies etc. With especially SWG being notable as that was a joint venture with a movie/multimedia company, namely Lucas Arts.
(3) Posted: 16:17 on 17 Sep 2009
Gunnar Petzall
This is a good reason why software patents as a whole should be abolished. Just make up words for ideas that have been around for ages, and hopefully get some nice court cases out of it.

This particular patent must have been very innovatively written (you couldn't SERIOUSLY suggest they came up with the idea of sharing content online!) to make MS back down.

Software patents are absurd and those registering them deserves the ninth circle of hell.
(4) Posted: 19:17 on 21 Sep 2009
Galtrovan
Paltalk and the lawyer that submitted the case should have been fined for filing a frivolous lawsuit. Seriously, you should not be able to patent and idea. You should be able to patent the implementation of the idea but not the idea itself. What would the computer world be like today if IBM was allowed to sue anyone that tried to create their own version of a personal computer? Or the inventor of the first word processor could sue anyone that tried to create a word processor? Or the company that made the first FPS game could sue anyone that tried to make an FPS?

This whole thing is ridiculous and should have been thrown out of court. Also, Microsoft should have fought this until Paltalk went bankrupt from pursuing the issue, not set a precedent because they did not want to be bothered with it.
please register or login to comment.
gamesbasesment PCGamestore.com

Popular Stories This Hour

Latest Comments

Game Releases

Most...